The gaming NFT project CyberKongz has become the latest target of regulatory pressure from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). On December 16, the project confirmed via X that it had received a Wells Notice, signaling the possibility of enforcement action. 

The Essence of the SEC's Claims

A Wells Notice is a formal notification from the SEC informing individuals or organizations that its staff has concluded an investigation and plans to propose enforcement action. It’s essentially the regulatory version of, "We need to talk," but with far more legal consequences and much less room for negotiation.

When gaming tokens, such as CyberKongz, receive an SEC Wells Notice, it typically means the commission is investigating whether these tokens violate U.S. securities laws.

The CyberKongz team shared that the SEC’s Enforcement Division raised concerns over the presence of an ERC-20 token in tandem with a blockchain-based game, claiming it wasn’t registered as a security.

CyberKongz team asked in a statement:

“If they cannot distinguish between a primary sale and a contract migration, what hope do we currently have for a clear regulatory pathway going forward?”

The issue stems from the migration of the Genesis Kongz contract back in April 2021, which the SEC is interpreting as a token sale. CyberKongz maintains this was "purely a technical update."

“We’ve been silently suffering for the past two years since the SEC first contacted us,” the team asserted, highlighting their frustration with the prolonged regulatory scrutiny.

Who is Also Under Fire?

CyberKongz isn’t the first (though we’re all hoping it’s the last) project to reel from the dreaded Wells Notice. On August 28, 2024, the SEC handed the same ominous letter to the NFT marketplace OpenSea.

“The SEC is threatening to sue us because they believe that NFTs on our platform are securities. We are shocked by this decision but are ready to stand our ground and fight,” OpenSea declared.

The OpenSea team pointed out that this SEC decision could “hit hundreds of thousands of online artists and creatives,” strangling their income streams and stifling innovation. “NFTs are art and collectibles, not securities. We shouldn’t be regulating digital art the same way we regulate collateralized debt obligations.”

The team emphasized the transformative impact of the NFT sector, which has empowered countless creators and independent developers.

We’ve heard so many stories about how NFTs have changed people’s lives: student artists finding full-time careers by selling their digital art; indie game developers instantly enabling open markets for in-game items; collectors from around the globe forming new communities centered on shared digital ownership.

To support the industry, OpenSea pledged $5 million to cover legal fees for NFT creators and developers facing similar Wells Notices. “Every creator, big or small, should have the freedom to create and experiment without fear of regulatory threats,” the company added.

The Consequences for Web3

Regulation through enforcement, as critics of the SEC argue, risks stifling innovation and creating uncertainty for all market participants.

Jihoz Zirlin, co-founder of Axie Infinity, voiced his support for CyberKongz, stating:

You know you’re part of a revolution when you start getting persecuted. I’m confident that a new administration will put an end to the persecution of our people.

For now, the NFT industry remains under pressure, but it continues to show resilience. Despite the Wells Notice, the CyberKongz NFT floor price remains stable, while OpenSea has firmly committed to defending the rights of creators.

With each new move from the SEC, it’s becoming clear that the future of Web3 depends on regulators finding unified legal frameworks and the industry’s ability to adapt to them. When major players like OpenSea and CyberKongz refuse to back down, it sets a powerful precedent for the entire market.

Disclaimer: All materials on this site are for informational purposes only. None of the material should be interpreted as investment advice. Please note that despite the nature of much of the material created and hosted on this website, HODL FM is not a financial reference resource and the opinions of authors and other contributors are their own and should not be taken as financial advice. If you require advice of this sort, HODL FM strongly recommends contacting a qualified industry professional.